I wasn’t talking about moving them off the top line and I admitted that the Yale example was extreme. The point is that there’s a difference between GOAT and best program currently. Sports, like anything else, is a “what have you done for me lately” business. I think two of my teams (KU b-ball and KC Chiefs) have a great argument for being the best in their sport right now. But if they started to pile up some mediocre seasons, I wouldn’t be able to say that. I definitely wouldn’t go around beating my chest like Yet Another UK fan after a first round loss or losing season.
If you want examples of what I’m talking about, start with his posts. And I like Lurker, but he starts attention whore threads all the time, then labels people obsessed/jealous if they take the bait. JC makes a lot of boastful posts/attacks, then gets really defensive if you counter. Bert loves attention and loves to trash talk, but if you fire back he’ll whine like a baby and put you on ignore. Etc, etc.
Why is UCLA a bad comparison, btw? They’ve never had a long stretch of irrelevance and they’ve got a billion titles. Went to three straight final fours a little over a decade ago, won a title in the 90s, etc. Now that they’re consistently relevant again, they should probably be the ones beating their chests.
You could make an argument that Kentucky’s been a middle of the road program since 2015. No final fours, not a ton of tourney wins, and their average Kenpom rating is 18 in that span. Now they’ve had a few really solid teams in that stretch, but a lot of middle of the road programs have too.
Not talking trash…just saying. Kentucky still has a great argument for GOAT. Although, if UCLA continues what they’re doing, that conversation gets pretty interesting.
Oh I certainly agree that UK is not currently a top shelf program, Cal has really shit the bed badly and his holier-than-thou attitude really rubs me the wrong way. So yeah, UK is a notch below several programs right now.
But the programs making all the noise right now, are not too far removed from some darker years. Heck, UConn was garbage from 2014 until the 2023 title, Baylor and UVA, they have never been anything more than also-rans, Villanova was an early out almost every year until those two title runs and have returned to mediocrity since.
You brought up UCLA and said they never had a long stretch of irrelevance, I strongly disagree. They won it in '95 and with the exception of a couple recent sweet 16's, they have been a ghost. I believe they had a couple final 4's 10 years ago, but that's not current state of affairs.
You're crapping on UK, but saying UCLA should be in a group above UK. Well, compare the two programs, it's not close.
As far as what UK has done since 2015, come on, that Fox/Monk/Bam team was incredible. Got beat on a last second shot by the eventual champions. Then, the 2019 UK team lost in OT in the E8. To me, that’s not exactly the definition of irrelevance.
You brought up Lurker and Bert. Well, I've never seen Lurker go ape shit, or do more than post a couple of comments when it comes to this stuff. He's always been even keeled, so I'm stunned to see you list his name. I know Bert personally, you would like him if you met him, I really don't think he fits the description of what you said. Neither of these guys talks out of both sides of their mouths. I still don't see a shred of proof of the original accusation, which is that UK fans demand attention, then get mad when they get it. Bert and Lurker don't do that. Neither does JC.
Every fanbase has their fans that talk smack even when they’re standing there with black eyes and broken legs. Della does it. UK owns UT, swept them last year, but Della still comes on here and flies that UT flag like UT owns UK. There is a KU fan that will defend every KU discretion until death, but I can't recall who that is. The Louisville fans that come on here are hilarious. Even during the Katina Powell stuff, the Pitino/Sypher stuff, the Adidas stuff and the Dino Gaudio blackmail stuff, they STILL talked smack. Then there is UNCfaninKY, need I say more?
I think I have proven my point here, but we do agree, UK is not where it used to be currently, but you know as well as I do that all it takes is one Final 4 and that changes.