“Look what Thad Matta did over a decade ago” isn’t really an argument for where your team is now. I get that it is the only leg you have to stand on because Underwood is winning that conversation handily.
Holtmann inherited a good product and turned it into one that can’t compete for a Big Ten title over a 5 year span. Your program hasn’t finished above 5th in conference in 9 seasons. That’s who you are. You’re just a football school with a middle of the road Big Ten basketball team.
Don’t believe me? Iowa has finished with or above you in 4/5 seasons since Holtmann. I’m done beating this dead horse.
Edit: Looks like Illinois beats OSU again.