ADVERTISEMENT

Kansas

This is an endless circle.

You are creating your own ranking but at times using KenPom when needed .
According to KenPom KU has 3 Top 20 wins
Florida St has how many many?

Well if you just want to go by KenPom, FSU is ahead of Kansas. So I guess that ends that.

FSU and Texas have the same number of top 25 KenPom wins by the way. Neat.
 
They have less. At what point does a bad loss make up for 2-3 extra Ls on the schedule.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GE Nole
They have less. At what point does a bad loss make up for 2-3 extra Ls on the schedule.

According to KenPom

Kansas and Florida State are pretty much mathematically tied.

The difference comes in the bad L.
Florida State has at times been impressive but all data counts the same

We will see in another 30-45 days where Florida State is at

I think they have an advantage with their size in the backcourt.
 
According to KenPom

Kansas and Florida State are pretty much mathematically tied.

The difference comes in the bad L.
Florida State has at times been impressive but all data counts the same

We will see in another 30-45 days where Florida State is at

I think they have an advantage with their size in the backcourt.

If all data counts the same then...isn’t FSU equal to or better than Kansas, West Virginia, Oklahoma, Creighton, and Texas Tech?
 
  • Like
Reactions: KisteK
If all data counts the same then...isn’t FSU equal to or better than Kansas, West Virginia, Oklahoma, Creighton, and Texas Tech?

Who said they weren't according to KenPom

I was arguing about AP rankings.
Like I said it looks like the writers punished Florida St for that UCF game

Not because they weren't ranked in the Top 10 to start the season
 
Who said they weren't according to KenPom

I was arguing about AP rankings.
Like I said it looks like the writers punished Florida St for that UCF game

Not because they weren't ranked in the Top 10 to start the season

Just find it hilarious that you “objectively” said Texas would embarrass FSU when Texas lost to Texas Tech and barely beat WVU.
 
Just find it hilarious that you “objectively” said Texas would embarrass FSU when Texas lost to Texas Tech and barely beat WVU.

Big difference here.
Texas Tech was on their way to getting embarrassed but they locked up on the defensive end
Like I said Florida St would have to

WVU played one of their best games of the year against Texas
This is a team who gave Gonzaga everything they could handle. So far has been Gonzaga's toughest challenge
 
Who said they weren't according to KenPom

I was arguing about AP rankings.
Like I said it looks like the writers punished Florida St for that UCF game

Not because they weren't ranked in the Top 10 to start the season
You don’t really know what you’re talking about, again. Even after the UCF game we were ranked. The Clemson game, when we lost, we were ranked the following poll as well. It was the Covid layoff that pushed us out of the rankings. Honestly, after winning two games last week, we should have been ranked, but whatever. The point is, if we had been top 10 to start the year, the loss the UCF probably drops us from 5th or 6th to 11-13. Then a loss on the road to a one loss team puts us 20th. All of the supporting wins for these teams with high rankings, for the most part, are against teams that lack any other wins against good competition that provides additional data to back up that ranking. It’s not just the BIG12, look at the Sec like Tennessee. So at that point you are left with the eye test and recent play as better indicators of the quality of a team. FSU can still get a 1 seed if they win out. That’s unlikely but a P5 with two losses all year would be able to argue that no matter the conference except maybe the PAC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GE Nole
Big difference here.
Texas Tech was on their way to getting embarrassed but they locked up on the defensive end
Like I said Florida St would have to

WVU played one of their best games of the year against Texas
This is a team who gave Gonzaga everything they could handle. So far has been Gonzaga's toughest challenge
We play defense just fine. If you haven’t watched our games I guess you could assume otherwise but I guess you haven’t.
 
We play defense just fine. If you haven’t watched our games I guess you could assume otherwise but I guess you haven’t.

There is a different level that is needed.

The difference is Texas isn't all the way there yet. May never be unlike Baylor

But both teams you have to bring in on the defensive end because they will.

Baylor is probably better in adjusting to teams turning it up
I have seen Texas go sideways in both their Losses.
 
Matters who is looking at it

That L really standouts for Florida State.
Why it will be almost impossible for them to get a #1 or #2 seed IMO.

KU still has a chance to get a #1 or #2.

So you think if FSU rolls thru the acc and win the accT they won’t be a 1/2 seed with if they only have 4/5 losses. Bc of a loss the what 2nd game of the season?

I’ll take that bet. I’ll bet that FSU has just as high of a seed as the second highest seeded big12 team.
 
The fact is as of now it’s gonzaga then it’s Baylor then it’s everyone else. No telling how it will all play out. Should be fun though.
 
So you think if FSU rolls thru the acc and win the accT they won’t be a 1/2 seed with if they only have 4/5 losses. Bc of a loss the what 2nd game of the season?

I’ll take that bet. I’ll bet that FSU has just as high of a seed as the second highest seeded big12 team.

That game sticks out.

Do you understand how the NCAA ranks teams

If UCF is a sub 100 team in the NET Ranking Florida St won't get a #1 seed
 
That game sticks out.

Do you understand how the NCAA ranks teams

If UCF is a sub 100 team in the NET Ranking Florida St won't get a #1 seed
Again, no way FSU won't get a 1 seed if they win out and are dominant doing it in a P5 conference. Basically, you'd have to have 4 other teams(Gonzaga, Baylor, etc) that win out as well. I'm fine with FSU being a 2 or 3, history bears out that those seeds are still quite likely to advance past the first round based on pedigree.
 
Again, no way FSU won't get a 1 seed if they win out and are dominant doing it in a P5 conference. Basically, you'd have to have 4 other teams(Gonzaga, Baylor, etc) that win out as well. I'm fine with FSU being a 2 or 3, history bears out that those seeds are still quite likely to advance past the first round based on pedigree.

Quad 1 games determine #1 seeds

Then they look at Quad 2 and Quad 3

I believe that was on Florida St's home floor...

Problem with the ACC is the amount of Quad 1 games
 
There is a different level that is needed.

The difference is Texas isn't all the way there yet. May never be unlike Baylor

But both teams you have to bring in on the defensive end because they will.

Baylor is probably better in adjusting to teams turning it up
I have seen Texas go sideways in both their Losses.
I don't know if you can even quantify "different level" with stats, but ask our recent opponents how their teams looked against our defense compared to other defenses they have played recently. I'm sure they'll tell you that their offense looked the least comfortable against our length and depth of talent that comes off the bench where the dropoff is hardly noticeable. our weakside defense has also improved quite a bit in the last 4 games, which had a lot to do with communication and integrating new players.
 
Quad 1 games determine #1 seeds

Then they look at Quad 2 and Quad 3

I believe that was on Florida St's home floor...

Problem with the ACC is the amount of Quad 1 games
Yeah, you're pontificating like people don't know the system but I'll tell you that a 2 loss, conference champion from P5 won't be shut out of a 1 seed unless there are several other extraordinary records to compete with.
 
I don't know if you can even quantify "different level" with stats, but ask our recent opponents how their teams looked against our defense compared to other defenses they have played recently. I'm sure they'll tell you that their offense looked the least comfortable against our length and depth of talent that comes off the bench where the dropoff is hardly noticeable. our weakside defense has also improved quite a bit in the last 4 games, which had a lot to do with communication and integrating new players.

Peaks and Valleys during the Basketball season

Every team has them

Have to be consistent
 
Yeah, you're pontificating like people don't know the system but I'll tell you that a 2 loss, conference champion from P5 won't be shut out of a 1 seed unless there are several other extraordinary records to compete with.

That doesn't mean anything ...

Only thing that matters is Quad 1-4 games

Difficult when you have as of right now 1 Quad 1 L

You can be a Conference Champion but you only have 2-3 Quad 1 wins you most likely won't get a #1 seed
 
That doesn't mean anything ...

Only thing that matters is Quad 1-4 games

Difficult when you have as of right now 1 Quad 1 L

You can be a Conference Champion but you only have 2-3 Quad 1 wins you most likely won't get a #1 seed
If we win out, we won't only have 2-3 quad 1 wins so that is really a baseless argument.
 
Peaks and Valleys during the Basketball season

Every team has them

Have to be consistent
What does that even mean? When you have a team that has 5 new players, and Covid, and the first game gets postponed, there are lots of things that can impact kids. It's fine if you say you haven't watched all of our games this year and you're just stating an opinion off box scores, but it is clear you don't have a good idea about our team
 
What does that even mean? When you have a team that has 5 new players, and Covid, and the first game gets postponed, there are lots of things that can impact kids. It's fine if you say you haven't watched all of our games this year and you're just stating an opinion off box scores, but it is clear you don't have a good idea about our team

You can take out a 4 game stretch for 20+ teams usually that make them look like juggernauts usually

This was my point

The key is continuing it
 
If we win out, we won't only have 2-3 quad 1 wins so that is really a baseless argument.

All these people sleeping on that elite basketball team in Tallahassee.
What is wrong with them.

For the most part people know who you are. The issue is some of you feel like you deserve even more respect

Nothing personal, brother

There isn't anything there that says Florida St deserves it
 
You can take out a 4 game stretch for 20+ teams usually that make them look like juggernauts usually

This was my point

The key is continuing it
Right, because you can eliminate a 4 game stretch of dominance, but want to focus on 1 game where the other team shot lights out and use that as the barometer for a team. Got it. If you can't see the inconsistency of your argument, I can't do critical thinking for you
 
All these people sleeping on that elite basketball team in Tallahassee.
What is wrong with them.

For the most part people know who you are. The issue is some of you feel like you deserve even more respect

Nothing personal, brother

There isn't anything there that says Florida St deserves it
But you're not even describing the situation. The whole premise of this conversation is how ridiculous the rankings are and the subjective nature of it. Has nothing to do with wanting to deserve respect. Conversely, this is the first season that Texas has even sniffed the top 10 in how long, and it is without a marquee win anywhere on their resume. Seems like you're willing to buy in with your bias a lot faster than is warranted
 
But you're not even describing the situation. The whole premise of this conversation is how ridiculous the rankings are and the subjective nature of it. Has nothing to do with wanting to deserve respect. Conversely, this is the first season that Texas has even sniffed the top 10 in how long, and it is without a marquee win anywhere on their resume. Seems like you're willing to buy in with your bias a lot faster than is warranted

I will give you this.

Would rather play Iowa or Wisconsin in the E8 than Florida State
 
  • Like
Reactions: KisteK
But not when he puts Florida State where you want them.

Faulty thinking

No, I’m saying Texas isn’t close to number 1 according to the link and the data. They are closer to 21 (Georgia Tech) than they are to 1. That’s just the facts.

So clearly, putting them #1 was way off.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT