It’s personal preference, I don’t think you’re wrong for picking Harbaugh but I also think it’s silly to shit on the Tucker pick. Michigan was borderline top 25, projected with 7.5-8.5 wins headed into the year and went 11-1. MSU was projected the worst team in our division and one of the worst in conference and we went 10-2. Both are really impressive.
@CardinalBoiler put it well though, it’s about who exceeded expectations the most not who won the most. If we are using basic math, Tucker outperformed his preseason win total expectations by the most and that’s why he won it.
All I did was call it interesting.
You’re completely overlooking performance over expectations for Michigan. Can you imagine the shit I would’ve gotten if I had predicted Michigan to the college football playoffs 3 months ago?