ADVERTISEMENT

Vote: Player A vs Player B

Which player had a better year?

  • Total voters
    12
hailtoyourvictor

hailtoyourvictor

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2012
36,063
28,160
113
Player A:
Team finished 12-21, Kenpom #84
Usage: 26.3
12.5 ppg
3.1 apg
1.8 rpg
1.7 spg
2.2 topg
34.7% 3pt %
40.5 FG %
102.9 offensive rating
104.1 defensive rating


Player B
Team finished 23-5, Kenpom #3
Usage: 16.2
9.5 ppg
3.1 apg
3.1 rpg
1.1 spg
1.1 topg
39.6% 3pt%
42.6% FG%
118.3 ortg
99.0 drtg
 
hailtoyourvictor said:
You joined a conversation you aren’t a part of just to take a personal dig at me?
Click to expand...
referee-ill-allow-it.gif
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Montana81, Villian07, UL_1986 and 7 others
I always love Hail making polls. He intentionally biases them and then expects fair conclusions to be drawn.
 
boilerzz said:
Is this like the 3rd time in a couple of weeks you took a silly argument within the B1G thread outside it looking for validation? Is it really that important to you?
Click to expand...

Its a way to take an disagreement and see what some unbiased posters have to say about it. It’s a weird thing to complain about ok a dying forum that has OT stuff on half the front page. If it doesn’t interest you, don’t participate.
 
VulvHa said:
Just go with the flow. Now they get go at it in two different threads about the same topic.
Click to expand...
Nah, he goes running to the polls when I fvck with him too much. It's what he does when he can't best me alone. I already showed my hand, and he still did it.
 
hailtoyourvictor said:
Sure go with that
Click to expand...
1. Loyola had 2 better tournament runs. No one debated that. That's what the poll said.
2. Before you posted this thread, I told you I was trolling you, and you still posted this thread because you got knotted up.
 
Jaycg15 said:
1. Loyola had 2 better tournament runs. No one debated that. That's what the poll said.
2. Before you posted this thread, I told you I was trolling you, and you still posted this thread because you got knotted up.
Click to expand...

1. We were debating who had the better past decade. That’s what the poll asked.

2. I posted this like 40 minutes before you admitted you were trolling.
 
Tell us who the players are already. Pretty obv player b had better stats on a better team which i assume is michigan. Playing on a good team can benefit you though, if ur on a bad team and the focal point of every defensive gameplan u come across.
 
Villian07 said:
Tell us who the players are already. Pretty obv player b had better stats on a better team which i assume is michigan. Playing on a good team can benefit you though, if ur on a bad team and the focal point of every defensive gameplan u come across.
Click to expand...
Trent Frazier at Illinois as a freshman and Eli Brooks at Michigan as a senior.
 
boilerzz said:
Trent Frazier at Illinois as a freshman and Eli Brooks at Michigan as a senior.
Click to expand...

That was going to be my question. I think that matters in that the soph leap is often (but not always) bigger than a junior to senior. Other factors are obviously how the player was used in their respective roles and whether the other team had to put them on the front page is the scouting report (talent around them).
 
FaithPlusOne said:
That was going to be my question. I think that matters in that the soph leap is often (but not always) bigger than a junior to senior. Other factors are obviously how the player was used in their respective roles and whether the other team had to put them on the front page is the scouting report (talent around them).
Click to expand...
That's essentially the argument that was had. Frazier was forced to be the first option while Brooks was the 4th or 5th.
 
Villian07 said:
Lmao wtf shoulda stayed out of it. Not even the same year and diff points in their careers.
Click to expand...

People were saying that Frazier’s freshman year was better than Brooks’ senior year. I said they were even, just different. Brooks slightly less counting stats but more efficient. Frazier not counting stats but less efficient. Flip a coin.

Their senior seasons were also a coin flip but the conversation was specifically about Illinois fans thinking Frazier’s freshman year was better.
 
hailtoyourvictor said:
Your home board died and ACC threads flop. I definitely don’t take offense to what you consider good forum banter.
Click to expand...
Probably bc we dont argue about players stats from different years, in diff points in their career like its even remotely relevant. Freshman frazier from 3 years ago vs brooks last year lol why the eff would u not just use fraziers numbers from last year, he played as well no?
 
Senoir david padgent had a better offensive post game than hunter dickerson will this year. Take that.
 
Last edited:
Villian07 said:
Probably bc we dont argue about players stats from different years, in diff points in their career like its even remotely relevant. Freshman frazier from 3 years ago vs brooks last year lol why the eff would u not just use fraziers numbers from last year, he played as well no?
Click to expand...

The conversation was about how often freshmen guards come into the league and have been abetter than a senior Eli Brooks was. Frazier‘s freshman year was cited. That is why.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Villian07
Villian07 said:
Senoir david padgent had a better offensive post fame than hunter dickerson will this year. Take that.
Click to expand...

The conversation was specifically about the odds of a freshman guard coming in and being better than Eli Brooks was last year. So we were looking at freshman seasons from PGs in the past compared to Brooks to see how common it is.
 
Villian07 said:
Probably bc we dont argue about players stats from different years, in diff points in their career like its even remotely relevant. Freshman frazier from 3 years ago vs brooks last year lol why the eff would u not just use fraziers numbers from last year, he played as well no?
Click to expand...
Its a shame your board went downhill because of one poster. He single handily made your board a ghost town.
 
hailtoyourvictor said:
The conversation was specifically about the odds of a freshman guard coming in and being better than Eli Brooks was last year. So we were looking at freshman seasons from PGs in the past compared to Brooks to see how common it is.
Click to expand...
Thank you, Nostradumbass.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Jaycg15
  • Poll

Vote: Would you start Eli Brooks at PG if you could pick any player from the Big Ten?

Replies
27
Views
2K
College Basketball Board
hailtoyourvictor
hailtoyourvictor
ADVERTISEMENT
Top Bottom
Back